|
The New York Review, 31.1.91
...The emphasis an Europe was evident in both the plan and the contents
of the exhibition. The Austrian architect Boris Podrecca designed it so
that visitors would come first into a central courtyard, or Lichthof,
in which they would move by way of an ascending ramp past images and artifacts
that represented the development, changes, and internal and external tensions
of European society from the battle of Waterloo to the apocalypse of the
First World War, which opened a new age. The outer rim of the exhibition
was divided into smaller rooms devoted to special themes, such as the
age of Metternich, the revolutions of 1848, Seen in their European dimension,
the national wars of the 1850s and 1860s, and the unification of Germany
and its new European role.
Thanks to the energy and diplomacy of the exhibition's director, Dr. Marie-Louise
Gräfin von Plessen, 280 museums and special collections collaborated
in sending exhibits to Berlin, including the Museum of the Army in Paris,
the National Historical Museum in Frederiksborg, Denmark, the Pinacoteca
di Brera in Milan, and museums in Florence, Vienna, Versailles, and London.
As a result visitors were privileged to see under one roof such masterpieces
of historical painting as Lanfredini's powerful representation of the
execution of the revolutionary priest Ugo Bassi by Austrian troops in
Bologna in 1849, Flandrin's portrait of Napoleon III, and the large canvas
that dominated the central court, Giuseppe Pelizza da Volpedo's Fiumana,
a study for his monumental painting The Fourth Estate. Foreign contributions
also added to the variety and scope of the exhibition's portrayal of the
political life of the age, the progress of industrialism, and the emergence
of the social problem and, in the case of the Prussian military victories
of the 1860s, enabled visitors to see these conflicts from the other side
of the hill. Particularly striking in this respect were Alphonse de Neuville's
painting of the dogged French defense in the churchyard of Saint-Privat
in 1870 and a desolate photograph showing the results of the German bombardment
of Strasbourg in the same year.
Through this century of political transformation, material progress, and
mounting violence, Otto von Bismarck made his way, first exploiting the
forces of revolutionary change, later, in his years as imperial chancellor,
seeking, not without success, to direct them in ways that would serve
his country, and in the end, like many another European leader, becoming
a kind of sorcerer's apprentice, overwhelmed by forces that he had helped
to release. The exhibition illuminated every phase of this Progress. There
were theme rooms devoted to Bismarck's Prussian ancestry and his life
as a landed proprietor, his diplomatic debut in Frankfurt in the 1850s,
and his foreign policy as Prussian minister president (which led him later
to confess, "If it hadn't been for me, there wouldn't have been three
great wars, 80,000 men would not have died, and parents, brothers, sisters
and widows would not be mourning. But that I have had to settle with God").
Other rooms contained materials that illustrated the various shapes of
his contorted relationship with the Reichstag, his savage offensive against
socialism and political catholicism, his social insurance policies, which
were trailblazing but fell so short of his own objectives that he never
even mentioned them in his memoirs, his ventures into overseas colonialism,
and finally - in one of the most interesting of these rooms - his transformation,
after his dismissal by William II in 1890, into a national cult figure.
For those interested in the inner life of the great man, a vestibule between
the central court and the theme rooms provided, among other things, family
portraits, pictures of him an horseback and with his dogs, two felt hats
and a hunting cap, a pair of the gigantic boots that he customarily wore,
which extended far above the knee and so impressed contemporaries that
Anton von Werner painted a picture of them, a portrait of his doctor Ernst
Schweninger, a pill box from the King Solomon Pharmacy in Berlin with
powders to be taken daily, a postcard from Bad Kissingen showing the Prince
Bismarck Weighing Machine and the variations in the chancellor's weight
between 1874 and 1893, and a collection of his favorite reading, the Schlegel
Tieck translation of Shakespeare in twelve volumes, the collected works
of Schiller and Heine, and the poems of Uhland, Chamisso, and Rückert.
Whether intended or not, the topicality of the Bismarck exhibition was
not in doubt. Even the rooms dedicated to periods and subjects that might
ordinarily seem remote had something to say to the present. In his introductory
essay in the exhibition's informative catalog, splendidly illustrated
with dozens of color plates, Lothar Gall makes the point that the history
of the revolutions of 1848 reveals agencies and provisional alliances,
as well as moods, symbols, and hopes, that Europeans who remember the
tumultuous events of 1989 will recognize in their own immediate experience.
At the same time, the presence in the exhibition of forms and structures
of history that have long since disappeared - such things as Prussia itself,
the institution of monarchy, and the nobility as a political and social
force may have suggested to reflective visitors that that disappearance
was not an unalloyed gain but one that has revealed problems and deficits
in modern society.
Of immediate contemporary relevance, finally, was one of the most interesting
features of the exhibition, an inner gallery flanking the central court
that was dedicated to what the catalog called the "deutsche Seelensuche"
and what we may call the German search for identity. Here were grouped
symbolic representations of Germanness, German Sehnsucht (longing), and
German national aspiration - Schloss Marienburg, the home of the Teutonic
Knights; Luther in his study; Cologne Cathedral; the Kyffhäuser,
where Frederick Barbarossa lies sleeping; a barrow or megalithic grave
under an ancient oak that invokes the memory of Klopstock's poem about
Hermann the Cherusker; the Lorelei; Hagen consigning the hoard of the
Niebelungs to the Rhine; and several portraits of Germania in full armor.
We are reminded by these Images of how many ill defined expectations were
aroused in the nineteenth century by references to German renewal or rebirth,
and Gall tells us that Bismarck, who in 1848 dismissed the aspiration
to unity as "German fantasizing" but later used it for his own
purposes, was always wary of its explosive potential. This he sought to
control by a statecraft based upon the anti ideological rationality that
he had learned as a Prussian diplomat and by an insistence after 1871
that Germany was a power with no territorial ambitions and a common interest
with its European neighbors in collaboration, interdependence, and peace.
Bismarck believed, in short, as most Germans and all of Germany's neighbors
do today, that a united Germany was safest when it was a member of an
effective European international System...
Gordon A. Craig
Otto Vossler, "Bismarck's Ethos",
Historische Zeitschrift, Vol. CLXXI, p. 286.
|
|